Welding Video of virtual simulator trainer- Using Stick SMAW

"Are virtual welding trainer stations replacing real life welding training? Say it aint so. "

After watching this Welding Video I have to Ask...

Is this what welding training has come to?

I am all for technology and cutting edge stuff, but holy crap! how is this better than actual welding? OK , OK I can see the obvious things. No smoke, no fumes, no Emissions to track, No on the job injuries while training, no consumables, ability to measure hand eye coordination using statistical control charts,... Wait a Minute...AM I about to talk myself into crossing over into the dark side of technology?

Dont count on it. I am old school.

I can however, see how this Virtual Welding Simulator trainer could be used by a large employer like a shipyard to select prime candidates for welding training programs and to not waste time and money on candidates who do not display hand eye coordination. But as far as teaching people to weld, I dont buy into it.

I want the welding student to be able to feel the electrode drag on the metal,

I want him to have an actual stinger to hold on to with actual not virtual jaws to clamp the stick in.

I want the welder to train like he will fight and fight like he trains.

The only way to do that is to train using actual and not virtual welders.

What are your thoughts?

What Other Visitors Have Said

Click below to see contributions from other visitors to this page...

Like you I'm old school I believe you need to feel and hear the process as well as see it. You use more of your senses in welding than just your eyes …

I have been in welding school full time for a little over a year now and have certifications in dualshield,innershield,7018,6010(light gauge), and just …

Lincoln electric's version 
I had a chance to operate one of these contraptions at a state level welding competition for high school students in which I was a judge. It was sponsored …

FlamingSource - virtual welding training  
In a perfect world, this MIGHT actually have merit, but we don't live or work there. After you've been dragging 100 feet of lead around all day (thru …

I was in a vid just like this for NGNN 
ahahaha i was in a video just like this for the Northrop Gruman Newport News Shipyard Welding School. we were testing the very first vr welding simulator. …

leave welding video page and learn more about stick welding

see other welding videos

welding videos - Shortage of welders

welding videos - welding contest champion

welding videos - virtual reality welding training

welding videos - welding training and welding schools

welding videos - tig welding clamps for headers

welding videos - aluminum brazing rods

welding videos - aluminum brazing rods

welding videos - gas tungsten arc welding clips

welding videos - jesse james choppers and welding

welding videos - how not to weld, seriously

welding videos - mig welding

welding videos - tig welding 4130 chromoly

welding videos - tig welding aluminum

welding videos - tig welding aluminum bike frame

welding videos - welder shortage jay leno

welding videos - welding videos reviewed
Welding Certification

Enjoy this page? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.